Titan762. It's my guess that most top players would agree with your comment, but we should acknowledge that it isn't black and white. It will depend on the player and I'd guess that some of the top players would still prefer HS. That doesn't make it right or wrong. It just is what it is.
I did just asked my daugher the question and, for her, it isn't close. Club is much more enjoyable. That isn't to say she doesn't enjoy HS, but she greatly prefers club. If forced to choose, which I hope doesn't happen, it wouldn't be a difficult decision for her.