So the conclusion I am coming too from many of the responses is that if you are having academic problems then you are granted another year of eligibility. So therefore if a junior fails a class and is not able to graduate on time and has to go back for another year, he should be granted another year of eligibility? If he is ruled eligible to play then this could open up a lot of discussions on what makes a player eligible and what doesn't. SCHSL could end up causing a lot of trouble by allowing Nathan to play.
