Keeperwatcher: Whilst I do not question your list I do find your logic interesting!
What if a player decides not to play soccer in college? Also, can we really say that all DI players are better than DII players? In addition, there are many college coaches out there that couldnt coach their way out of a wet paper bag, never mind rate a player! (Ever heard the comment big, fast and strong!)
So, whats my point ... Everyone will have their opinion and they are really all relative (to who knows what)!!
Carry on.