daddy, like i said, maybe they aren't necessarily logical people; or, maybe #3 above applies.
i know people who committed to div 1 schools while not playing academy, and their future college coach basically told them that they will be playing academy their senior year of high school.
i'm sure there are plenty of reasons i can't think of, but the only ones i come up with at the moment for why your buddies think they have a better shot at a school by playing at cesa is 1) the school is in cesa's backyard, or 2) the college coach and cesa docs are, you know, real tight.