SC Soccer Forums SCSoccer.com Forums Boys Varsity Soccer Best goalie in 1A

GOOB- Deffinately not gonna disagree with you on that one. You're a great keeper in my opinion. I think you could've saved the first PK in yesterday's game and then in our first meeting at our place there was 2 shots that we're too great, but you just dove the wrong way on. Good luck the rest of the season though.

Goob is the best..He's just a little "lack-a-daze-ackle" on the pk's..

I guess that's your opinion, but if he's slack on PK's then what rights does he have to say he's the best. Being able to stop PK's is a large majority of being a good goalie, and since the SCS goalie has stopped 50% of the Dixie Pk's I'd have to put him ahead of Goob. Not that goob isn't good, b/c he's probably close to as good as the SCS goalie in the games, but the SCS goalie is in a completely different league when it comes to PK's.

Stopping PK's is a part of being a goalie, but I don't necessarily think it's as large a part as you think. It's mostly (but not all) a guessing game. Guess right and you have a pretty decent chance of looking good. Guess wrong and you can at least blame it on the defense. I would say that positioning and reaction are probably a stronger key to being a good goalkeeper.

^ good point.. I really didn't think much of SSC's goalie..ITs a guessing game.. I think goob is still better he makes very nice save beside's pk's..

Let's just leave it at they're both great goalie's. One's just better at Pk's.

I'm the sexiest...

DCA6767 - don't just leave it anywhere.
#3 - SCS's goalie is better, hands down. Better at PK's, and better in the game. I don't care what you say, we've won 2 games against you guys, because of goalie's. If yours was better than ours, he would have stopped our PK's, he DIDN'T. Our goalie, however, did stop over half of yours.....so this must mean your goalie is better, right? No. He is a great goalie, don't get me wrong. But if you are going to compare the two, most would agree, SCS's is better.

No... We can't shoot Pk's.. HANDS DOWN.. Like your fellow goalie said.. "I admit, I couldn't of block our teams shot either." If it comes down to it, ya'll have better pk shooters than us, not goalie..

Ok if you want to look at it that way, but also take into account that I think GOOB is a senior, and our goalie is only a sophmore so just imagine how much better than GOOB he'll be his senior year.