From what I saw, the backup keeper from BHHS is pretty damn good. He made some real good saves vs. Barnwell, even though they lost the game. He can stand in pretty well, but the defense is alot different when D-Mac is in there.
Is the backup keep the guy that normally plays midfield and is a big physical guy? I know that they have another big midfielder, but the guy with the braids can knock people around pretty good.
As long as you all do not lose #4 you are straight. That guy is awesome. #5 and #17 are good defenders as well. Your D is great...