Having heard this song and dance last year when Alex Mouton did not make All-State from RNE I can tell you what our AD told us about the All-State selections.
(1) Our head girls coach (who was new) did not nominate her, thus she was not eligible to be picked. This was truly unfortunate for her, but part of the coach's responsibility per the mandate by the association.
(2) Forms are distributed at the ADs meeting in March (allegedly) and I know have been online since the beginning of the regular season, because I made sure our new coach nominated several RNE players for these honors.
(3) I know good players are omitted, but it's not always because the selection committee erred, but perhaps the coach of those players themself.
I'd like to hear from the all-state director, Kevin Darlington (Ridge View) about this. Is there a girls' all-state director as well?