I did not say that I would not take Geathers, because personally I would take both of them. However, your logic is alittle lost. You state head to head. however, last time I checked, SA had the best GK in the state playing for them (that is a consensus of the board). I have not even seen the NW GK mentioned on here. Would Geathers have scored two if Goose was with NW? Who would have won the head to head then as you state? I honestly do not know
On top of everything else, Arroyo had others at NW who scored numerous goals. Geathers did alot on his own as evidenced by scoring 11 of his teams 15 goals in the playoffs I believe. someone correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that is what I read.