High shcool is where you go to learn, to be educated. Sports are a side note to that. The rule states that you have 8 semesters(or 4 years) to complete that eligibility. If you have to take a year off from sports to improve grades so be it, you lose a year of eligibility. Not playing is the result of not making the grade. Why should he be an exception? Grades first! He and his guardians choose to take a year for grades, well, that is a year he loses. If the high school league lets him play then they might as well let all kids, passing or not, good grades or bad, participate in the athletic programs or give them an extra year. Does this sound right? No. Sorry Arroyo, you used your time, its not punishment but a rule.