This is such a stupid rule. I believe that most HSLs only have the 8 semester rule. What is the difference of playing club ball in the fall as compared to playing high school ball? I would consider the club ball to be more beneficial, but hey, most high school leagues are screwed up anyways. Go ahead and call them and ask them how many lawsuits are filed on an average year...it is shocking! Explain the advantage, and I might listen to that argument.