Ok. I'll give it to you if most of your players(all but 2 or 3 according to you) came from a Catholic middle school in the area. Making those schools feeder schools. That is fine with me. My problem is a player who goes to public school all through his career and then attends a competitive high school but the attends BE for two or three years to win a AA championships.
My only point is that at 850, you are one of the largest AA schools. In fact you are the 102nd largest school in SC. The closest school above you that i KNOW is AAA is #94 Eau Claire. Most AA schools have about 600-650. If BE adds about 25 students, they will have to move up to AAA. BE is listed at 861 students and Eau Claire is listed as having 886. Keep in mind, there are 7 schools in between them that may be AAA, I am just unsure about those teams.