I know this gets said all the time, but you can't solely judge the best keeper by goals allowed. There are PLENTY of other factors that go into how many goals you have scored against you. Strength of your defense is the most obvious one and of course who you play. Having shutouts against teams like LR, RNE, Hartsville, Rock Hill aren't really saying much about the quality of a keeper. It's hard to judge a keeper without actually seeing him play so I guess we can just have some more fun and continue with this debate forever.... and ever.