First I'll state I do not agree with the ridiculous rules
However as written I see the following
1- the fall club season is CLOSED SEASON 2- The organized practice scenario clearly has been violated ( and may I add not just Coach Wren but I can come up with many in the Cola area) 3- Using school property was violated
so what was the winning appeal based on?
And why were Gilbert Girls prevented from post-season play but these boys beat the sentence?