Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

he put the flag up as soon as the ball was played.the offside player was not involved in the play.not rally close to it.i have seen some that would call it and some wouldnt.some wouldnt know to.
great game by both sides.



The question is: What was the intention of the player passing the ball? If their intention is to pass to a player and that player is offsides, even if the ball gets deflected (or the pass is bad) and the offsides player never receives it, it can still be called offsides.

One thing about soccer officiating, the calls are extremely subjective. Almost every call will have differing opinions because every call is practically an official's judgement call.

Heck, there are even different standards between boys rules and girls rules. You never see an official say "the handball was inadvertant" in a boys game, but in a girls game, they are allowed to make that distinction because the girls are allowed to protect themselves using their arms.



i do not think the ball was intended for the player called offsides but i could be wrong.the player that recieved the ball was not offsides and she split the defense and went around the goalie to put the ball in the net.so i guess you would have to say the player called offsides was not the intended one.the call could of went either way.if i was a mauldin parent then it was the right call.if i was a dorman parent then i think it was the wrong call.
both sides played great and it was worth the ride to see it.




The Dorman player did all this after the ref blew his whistle to stop the play. It's easy to score when your the only one trying.



i think this is going to lead into something other than why the topic was started.i do not think anyone except the person that started this topic is arguing with the call.a very good game and mauldin came out on top.no one can say they did not deserve it.the one thing no one is talking about is their goal off a nice corner.mauldins defense is the reason they won.they close on forwards as fast as any team i have seen this year.as far as when the ref blew his whistle i could not tell you because of the (mauldin boys choir that was in front of me) but they got split and the goalie did try.once the forward went by the defenders they did not chase her down like they had all night if that is what you are talking about.