This may be a false assumption but I am from the school that the coach of the year is selected on the performance and record of his or her team.

Coach A
His or Her team is:

Region play-8-6
Over all-12-10-2
Eliminated in the first round of Playoffs.


Coach B
His or Her team is:

Region play-12-2(Co-Champs)
Over all-16-4-1
Eliminated in the Lower State Finals
Coach B's Team beats Coach A's team Twice
Coach B starts 5 Freshman

Based on the records,Coach B is my COY
Am I wrong?