Quote:

Even if he WAS onside -- and like I said, it was close -- you guys presume that a no-whistle-play-on would have resulted in a goal. I've seen at least half a dozen times this year when a kid went 1-v-1 on a keeper and shot the ball high/wide or saw the shot saved.



If you saw the 2A match, you would have seen a couple of those. Pro's miss too >> YouTube - Klose misses while in the 6yd Box <<

Quote:

I agree...it was close and could have gone either way. I tend to favor the offense on close offside calls.
But, with that said, I don't recall the keeper letting up, or even knowing the LR signaled Offsides. I do however recall the ball going into the net.

(edited....darn, can't even spell with spell check on)




They call the offside against Irmo, but the same exact situation occurred during the game for Wando EXCEPT they did not call Offsides when it was VERY VERY close. The attack for Wando's final goal, to my eyes, could have been offside. I looked at the AR and as he was running he started to pull the flag from under his arm to call it, but then put it back. I mean, it was a pretty good game. I really enjoyed it, but if they are going to make calls, be consistent. Then, by saying that we go back to the conversation of having a Ref Rating System to have some sort of consistency.