I dont watch a lot of high school soccer, being strictly a club coach, so i cant assume to know where a lot of the players from club play their high school soccer.
As Coach Hamil stated, the High School Sports Report was THE outlet for high school soccer in the '90s. I havent followed if much recently, so i cant know for sure how their involvment relates.
That being said, players selected for a newspaper team may or may not be the most deserving players. Just to select an All State team, i think there should be 11 players on that team. Just think it fits the mold of a team.....
HSSR used to have a Top-50 listing each year. Maybe they can come back with that to appease the masses.