As with this post and the discussion therein, this is an emotional discussion about what is supposed to be unemotional (objective) subject.
I am for providing feedback on performance IF the emotion can be removed (again objective).
I for one have stated before a game that ref "such and such" is a good referee only to then see them calling a game completely inconsistent with past performance.
It happens they are human and the two man system in HS does not help
One thing that I have always said no matter the sport - you should never let it come down to a call or non-call to determine whether you win or lose
Fitness to officiate a game should be mandatory what that should be I leave to the ref association - assignors should assign games based on competition level, experience and fitness.... but that may trump the $$/game if the experienced guy has to drive a long distance
And lastly; a while back there used to be a ref who lived in the Spartanburg area (I think) that was a normal MLS referee and he did a couple of HS games... an experienced guy, fit and of the highest caliber available... and still half the stadium was unhappy... it is part of the business.
