I have to agree. The rest of the world, and the rest of soccer in the U.S., understands the point system, and it works. Why does high school have to do it just with wins and losses.
On the other hand, it could be worse. When my high school team tied a state semi-final game even after overtime periods, the state of Pennsylvania used the number of corner kicks to decide the winner (this was in 1973, and my team lost). Think of that the next time your game is decided by kicks from the spot.