That is exactly what happens upstatesoccermom. Look at who sits on the selection committee, and then look at the players that were selected and the schools that they attend. In 2A boys there were two players that were selected that weren't represented by a coach on the committee. It was my understanding that this was an award based on individual merit not the accomplishments of the team that the player plays on. I would like to see the statistics of the players that were selected to see just how deserving they were.
