If I have to pick just one factor by which to judge a coach, then I pick whether he wins or loses on the largest stage possible. Rhodes is one of two South Carolina coaches of whom I'm aware who have won titles on the regional stage.
If I have to pick just three factors by which to judge a coach and wins/losses aren't part of it, then I pick the ability to attract talent, the ability to train ambition, and the ability to create and communicate strategy and tactics on the field. I've seen first-hand Rhodes abilities on the first two of these factors; I'm not a soccer coach and I don't feel qualified to comment on the third, so I tend to defer to what I mentioned in the first paragraph.
cscsoccerfan: There is no doubt that Rhodes is controversial. However, I've met very few very high quality coaches [or anyone else in any other walk of life] that aren't. I could go through a handful of the most successful coaches in the state and tell you the trash on each one of them, simply because their peers, parents, and players talk so much about them. CSC, which is my favorite club in the Columbia area, is not exempt.
My Left Foot: Couldn't agree more, I think we said the same thing but you said it better.
Lowerstate4A: As I understand it he's in both Aiken and Lexington; it's a 45-minute drive so not a very big deal -- but I don't know the "latest" of anything.
Cola Fan: You should remember Rhodes, it was only last September that you announced the Fire was
basically dissolved. [Note: I predicted that Eastside would beat BC on the girls side, so I'm far from omniscient myself.] There's a lot that goes on between the times that the "ball is rolled out and the players play" and Rhodes seems to have a knack for making some of the best players better.
R1C: The ability to attract and train talent is huge. It might be bigger in club than high school, but I would argue that with the increasing amount of competition for the time of players [both from within high school sports and from outside of those sports] that it's of growing importance in the high school ranks as well.