Benp...you are correct regarding playing year round. The player that focuses on one sport winds up improving in that sport to his highest capabilities.
You may have missed my point though. Those club players just happen to live in the same district. Whereas, at these so called private schools they do not have such limitations. I too beleive that if the schools are going to compete against each other than the playing field must be level regarding "all" rules regardless of who or what government system is setting those rules.
Let me look at it in another way. I believe most of these public high school rules and regulations have been setup to deter recruiting by the high schools. If (hypothetically speaking) I wanted to get a club team to attend one high school there is no way (by law) that I could do such in a public school setting. However, for these private schools it would only take inventive car pooling. That does not seem right. Let's even the playing field.
