a fan: Here's a perspective that no one else has taken in all of this: the coaches that were there selected two South Aiken players instead of adding two more of their own players. If a conspiracy was hatched among all but the South Aiken coach [I'm keying on the term "alleged" above], then I would have hoped that the conspirators would have had the brains and the courage to go all the way and shut out South Aiken completely.
Again, I don't see any villians here, either from South Aiken or the rest of the high schools, just a potential process problem.