I think you misunderstood my post. I am not against an evaluation system. In fact, I pointed out that one exists for football and basketball and as far as I know it works well. I don't know that soccer doesn't have one as I don't do soccer. My only point was that it would be a mistake to include coaches in the evaluation (basketball and football don't). You are correct, that an evaluation system would lead to incentive to improve, but with the current shortage of officials, all are needed to work varsity games, so in addition to an evaluation system, ideas are needed to recruit more and retain more officials.
Oh, and I never said two-man was the worst, just not the best.
