Chico,
I agree that rules should not be overly burdensome in restricting player movement. I also have a little compassion for teams that lose players any time outside of the May/June tryout period. So, I guess I'm caught in two minds here.
Also remember:
What is good for R3PL is not often good for the SCYSA Challenge League.
What is good for CESA....is not always good for the other clubs/teams competing in South Carolina.