G&B ... therefore, following your argument The HSL does not have a leg to stand on if a player in the greenville area goes from one school to the other?

When the boy from greenwood wanted to go to Byrnes to play football he was stopped because of the HSL transfer rules, i.e you are not zoned there so why are you changing if you are not moving?

Eventually this was resolved, but why is it any different than Sallie moving from Riverside to Greenville High School to play Volleyball without actually moving?